Curious About the Lives of North Korea’s Isolated Athletes? Here’s a Glimpse
TOKYO — The arrival of 22 athletes from North Korea to compete in the Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang, South Korea, has been greeted by a predictable news media scrum, with journalists scrambling to coax comments from these emissaries of one of the world’s most reclusive countries.
Like many things known about North Korea, its state athletic program is obscured by propaganda and limited access. But cobbling together information from the country’s state news media, analysts, defectors and athletes who have competed alongside North Koreans has given us some insights.
Who are the North Korean athletes competing in Pyeongchang?
This year, only two athletes in the North Korean contingent — the figure skating pair Ryom Tae-ok and Kim Ju-sik — qualified for the Games on merit by placing at a competition last fall in Oberstdorf, Germany. The rest, including short track speedskaters and both alpine and cross-country skiers, have been granted exemptions by the International Olympic Committee. A dozen North Koreans have also joined the South Korean women’s ice hockey team. The expectation is that few, if any, of North Korea’s athletes will end up on a medal podium.
今年，朝鲜代表团中只有两名运动员，即花样滑冰双人组合廉太钰(Ryom Tae-ok)和金柱希(Kim Ju-sik)的成绩有资格参加冬奥会。他们在去年秋天德国奥伯斯多夫的比赛中取得了名次。其余的运动员，包括短道速滑选手和高山及越野滑雪选手，均被国际奥委会(International Olympic Committee)免去了资格限制。还有十余名朝鲜运动员加入了韩国女子冰球队。外界预计，朝鲜运动员中即便有人登上领奖台，人数也很少。
Why is North Korea sending athletes?
Their participation is a potential publicity coup for Kim Jong-un, the country’s leader, as it shifts attention away from his nuclear program and human rights abuses.
“Just by participating in these high-profile games, North Korea comes across as far more empathetic,” said Lee Sung-yoon, a professor of Korean studies at Tufts University.
“只用参加这些广受关注的比赛，朝鲜就能给人更有同理心的印象，”塔夫斯大学(Tufts University)朝韩研究教授李成允(Lee Sung-yoon)说。
“Because they are so poor and backward, we tend to be somewhat fascinated by any glimpse of North Koreans,” Mr. Lee said. “And when they are working so hard you tend to root for them because they are such an underdog in so many ways.”
How has North Korea performed at past Olympics?
North Korean athletes have competed on and off in the Games since 1964, when Han Pil-hwa won the silver medal in the 3,000-meter women’s speedskating race. That was the first of only two medals that North Korea has won at any Winter Games. It did not send any athletes to the 2014 Games in Sochi, Russia.
The country has fared better at the Summer Olympics, winning a total of 54 medals in judo, weight lifting and gymnastics. At the Rio Games in 2016, North Korean athletes won seven medals.
Who are North Korea’s most successful athletes?
North Korea has won a total of 16 gold medals. One of the most well-known winners is Hong Un-jong, who captured a gold medal for gymnastics vault at the 2008 Beijing Olympics. She also became an internet sensation after she posed for a selfie with the South Korean gymnast Lee Eun-ju at the Rio Games in 2016.
朝鲜总共获得了16枚金牌。最著名的金牌获得者之一是洪恩贞(Hong Un-jong)。她在2008年北京奥运会上获得了一块跳马金牌。此外，她还因为在2016年里约奥运会上与韩国体操运动员李恩珠(Lee Eun-ju)自拍而在网上走红。
When Kye Sun-hui won gold at the 1996 Atlanta Games, she was the youngest gold medalist ever in judo. She also won a silver medal in 2000 in Sydney, Australia, and a bronze at the 2004 Athens Games.
North Korea does well in judo: At the 2012 London Games, An Kum-ae, then 32, was a surprise gold medalist in the women’s 52-kilogram category.
It is also a weight lifting powerhouse. At the London Games, North Korea won three gold medals. At the Rio Games, North Korean weight lifters took home four medals.
North Korea’s women’s soccer team is ranked 11th in the world, although the team was banned from the World Cup in 2015 after five players tested positive for steroids.
Wasn’t Kim Jong-il said to be an amazing athlete?
According to the state-controlled media in North Korea, Kim Jong-il, father of the current leader, Kim Jong-un, was such a naturally gifted sportsman that he bowled a perfect 300 on his first outing at Pyongyang Lanes in the North Korean capital and somehow shot five holes in one to come in 38 under par the first time he played golf. Who knows what he could have accomplished had he competed internationally in judo or weight lifting.
At international competitions, victorious North Korean athletes must say they owe their success to their leader and country.
What do we know about the North Korean athletic program?
Analysts who study North Korea say athletes are typically recruited as young children whose talent is spotted on the schoolyard. They are likely to be groomed similarly to athletes in other regimes such as China or the former Soviet Union. The military, the police and some factories also sponsor their own sports teams.
Because North Korea is such a poor country, its state sports system is probably underfunded compared with China or Russia, whose athletes have been accused of doping. (Russia has been nominally barred from Pyeongchang because of an elaborate state-run doping scheme.) When players on North Korea’s women’s soccer team tested positive for steroids in 2015, officials blamed traditional Chinese medicines made from musk deer glands given to players who had been struck by lightning.
In North Korea’s sports program, family loyalty may be as important as athletic ability, said Toshimitsu Shigemura, a professor at Waseda University in Tokyo and an expert on North Korea’s leadership.
东京早稻田大学(Waseda University)教授、研究朝鲜领导层的专家重村智计(Toshimitsu Shigemura)表示，在朝鲜的体育系统中，家庭的忠诚度可能与运动能力同等重要。
Mr. Shigemura said that athletes tend to come from families that hew closely to state ideology and have good connections.
The regime also focuses on sports where it believes its athletes can excel internationally, including wrestling, martial arts and soccer.
Do the athletes get special treatment?
Admission to the elite level of sports is probably a way for athletes and their families “to secure a decent lifestyle in North Korea,” said Christopher Green, a North Korea analyst in Seoul, South Korea.
An Yong-hak, a Japanese-born ethnic Korean who played for North Korea’s national men’s soccer team between 2002 and 2012, said that when he practiced with the team in Pyongyang, “there was always meat, fish, rice, soup, vegetables and plenty of food.” In a country where hunger is still common, such square meals would be a privilege of team membership.
Those who bring glory to the regime may even be rewarded with cars or houses, but those prizes are probably very limited, said Hwangbo Young, 38, a former North Korean women’s ice hockey player who defected to South Korea in 1997.
“These cases are rare,” said Ms. Hwangbo, “and limited only to gold medalists of major international events like the Olympics or the World Cup games.”
If they don’t do well, are they punished?
Rumors abound that athletes who fail to win in international competitions are exiled to coal mines or gulags, but there is little evidence of that.
Even after teams underperform, their players reappear at subsequent international competitions, said Udo Merkel, a senior lecturer at the University of Brighton, where he specializes in sports sociology. “So I don’t believe some of the stories that they are locked up in jail,” Mr. Merkel said, “because half a year later when they play the next qualifying match, you see the same names and players.”
布赖顿大学(University of Brighton)研究体育社会学的高级讲师乌杜·默克尔(Udo Merkel)表示，运动员即使表现不佳，还是会在之后的国际比赛中亮相。“所以，我不相信他们被关进监狱的故事，”默克尔说，“因为半年后，在下一场资格赛中，你还会看到那些运动员和他们的名字。”
In 2010, for example, the North Korean men’s soccer team lost 7-0 to Portugal at the World Cup in South Africa — a game that was reportedly broadcast live in Pyongyang. According to Mr. An, the goalkeeper who allowed those seven goals is still on the team. There were reports, however, that the team was subjected to a public criticism session in Pyongyang that lasted six hours.
How can North Korea afford a sports program?
Soon after Mr. Kim took over leadership of the country nearly six years ago, he “really began to put money and political energy and time into developing an internationally competitive athletic prowess,” said Katharine H.S. Moon, a professor of political science at Wellesley College.
韦尔斯利学院(Wellesley College)的政治学教授凯瑟琳·H·S·穆恩(Katharine H.S. Moon)表示，近六年前，金正恩掌权后不久，他“真的开始把金钱以及政治精力和时间投入到培养具有国际竞争力的运动技能上了”。
According to an analysis of North Korea’s national budget announcements by Curtis Melvin, a senior fellow in the U.S.-Korea Institute at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies, Mr. Kim has invested steadily in sports, giving it about 6 percent of the country’s budget last year.
根据约翰·霍普金斯大学国际问题高级研究学院(Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies)美韩研究所(U.S.-Korea Institute)高级研究员柯蒂斯·梅尔文(Curtis Melvin)对朝鲜国家预算报告进行的分析，金正恩一直在体育方面进行稳定投资，去年的国家预算约有6%用于体育。
Since 2012, North Korea has built a new rink for ice and roller skating, soccer academies and a horseback riding club. It also renovated a large stadium in Pyongyang with volleyball, table tennis and basketball courts (the American basketball player Dennis Rodman famously crooned “Happy Birthday” to Mr. Kim in that stadium during a 2014 visit).
Jean H. Lee, a former Associated Press bureau chief in Pyongyang and now a global fellow at the Woodrow Wilson Center in Washington, said that when she visited the new skating rink in 2012, it was “state of the art and perfectly maintained.” She said she saw Canadian and European-made ice resurfacers as well as high-end figure and hockey skates, suggesting that the regime had figured out how to skirt sanctions on luxury goods.
前美联社(Associated Press)平壤分社社长、现华盛顿伍德罗·威尔逊中心(Woodrow Wilson Center)全球研究员吉恩·H·李(Jean H. Lee)表示，2012年她参观那个新溜冰场时，发现它“非常先进，维护得很好”。她表示，她看到了加拿大和欧洲制造的冰面修整器，以及高档花样滑冰鞋和冰球鞋，这表明，朝鲜政府找到了绕开制裁、购买奢侈品的途径。
Mr. Kim also built the Masikryong Ski Resort, where some South Korean athletes practiced with their North Korean counterparts last week.
How much do the athletes get to see of the countries they visit?
When the North Korean figure skating pair of Mr. Ryom and Ms. Kim trained over the summer in Montreal with the French Canadian coach Bruno Marcotte, they were taken shopping by Mr. Marcotte’s wife, Meagan Duhamel, a champion figure skater.
当朝鲜花样滑冰双人组合廉太钰和金柱希夏季在蒙特利尔跟着法裔加拿大教练布鲁诺·马科特(Bruno Marcotte)训练时，马科特的妻子——花样滑冰冠军梅根·迪阿梅尔(Meagan Duhamel)曾带他们去购物。
The 12 North Korean women’s ice hockey players who have been added to the roster of the South Korean team are probably getting glimpses of the comparative wealth of their South Korean teammates.
Caroline Park, 28, a Canadian-born team member, said that when she and her teammates practiced with the North Koreans late last month, they ate together every day. Ms. Park said she noticed the North Koreans did not have cellphones.
And even further afield, Han Kwang-song, a player for the North Korean national soccer team, is currently on loan to a professional team in Perugia, Italy. There, he is also getting a taste of social media: He has a private Instagram account, @han.k.s.32.
Have any North Korean athletes ever defected?
No North Korean athletes have defected during the Olympics, although one defected in 1991 during a world judo championship in Spain. Ms. Hwangbo, the hockey player, defected to South Korea through China with her family in 1997.
The athletes are carefully screened before being allowed to participate in international events. Even if they wanted to defect, they will be closely watched by North Korean minders. In Pyeongchang, South Korean security forces will also be watching, as neither side will want the publicity of a defection undercutting the message of unity between the two Koreas. Even the women’s ice hockey players are not staying in the same dorm as their South Korean teammates.
What is more, said Benjamin Young, a Ph.D. candidate at George Washington University who has written about the North Korean athletic program, the athletes “have families in the North, and they are the most loyal and treated very well by the regime.”
曾就朝鲜运动员计划写过文章的乔治·华盛顿大学(George Washington University)博士候选人本杰明·杨(Benjamin Young)说，除此之外，运动员们“还有家人在朝鲜，他们是最忠实于这个政权、获得良好待遇的人。”